Growth

2024-10-25 at 10:56 

Every effort is made to achieve economic growth. A topical book on this theme is "Growth” by Daniel Susskind. What makes it topical is that currently there is no growth, which is a major cause for concern. Germany is seeing negative growth for the second year running. Europe's growth figures are weak. Growth is faltering in China, which is declaring support in order to stimulate the economy. The United States is still going strong, at least for now. Is there something to be done?

What is growth?

Growth is a new phenomenon. The start of industrialisation 200 years ago brought about a revolution that had never been seen before. Economies grew and the fruits of growth were shared by those involved, with some benefits also trickling down to citizens close to the process. The sources of growth were industrialisation, energy, production and innovation, as well as improved sanitary conditions. The social system, economic thinking and education supported people's entrepreneurial spirit and success.

As a concept, GDP was born in the 20th century, which makes it a relatively recent economic indicator.  Indeed, one of the messages of the book is that GDP – or whatever the right indicator may be – responds to the times and is definable.

Gross domestic product has traditionally been used as a measure of the performance of the productive economy. Over time, however, economies have shifted from pure manufacturing to services and from producing new things to recycling old things. At the same time, services that were previously provided ‘for free’ have become part of GDP. Consequently, GDP – and economic growth – responds to the times, measuring performance according to the definition of economy prevailing at any given time. If we were to measure economic growth now by the 1920s standards, it might look very different.

However, 100 years ago, a large part of the market capitalisation of stock exchanges was determined by the price of railway company stocks. Now the US stock markets are dominated by technology companies that are growing at a dizzying pace and have high growth expectations. Changes in market values are only natural and happen all the time. In the stock markets, the ‘market’ is redefined on a daily basis.

What about ‘degrowth’?

In a degrowth economy, the economy does not grow. If nothing else, degrowth can then perceived as a solution to environmental problems. Degrowth means recognition of the limits of growth on the planet. The problem is, however, that there are a lot of people in the world who are hungry for growth.

The book argues that the problem with the ‘degrowth’ movement is that it does not approve of green growth. But green growth could provide at least a partial answer to many environmental problems. Today’s technology permits new productive concepts that allow growth to contribute to a better balance with nature. Not even green growth is the right medicine to all ailments, and its implementation is riddled with problems.

The book's solution to the ‘degrowth’ debate is to provide tools for defining growth. Hence, growth should be redefined. For example, growth has long been driven by the manufacturing industry. However, a transition has already taken place because much of growth is generated by services. Moreover, economic activity did not use to include areas that are now part of the concept, as pointed out above.

Growth choices

Usually, efforts to achieve growth make it necessary to make choices. A classic choice is the question of how to deal with the natural environment and emissions. Often, these choices are not mutually exclusive, because both can be promoted simultaneously. Emissions can be reduced by developing technology while at the same time enabling and supporting growth. New technologies call for innovation, including public support for science and research.

Emissions from industrial processes are still a reality today, despite the drive towards zero-emission production and economy. Especially on a global scale, the problem with emissions appears indisputable. Setting an emissions levy or tax (carbon tax) high enough is an easy example of a choice. Such a levy or tax will raise costs for consumers and industry in the short term, but in the long term, as consumption patterns change, the benefits will be clear in terms of a cleaner environment and less drastic climate change. In this sense, the ball is in the decision-makers’ court. Another question is whether we will actually be able to make the right decisions and choices.

One of the key messages of Susskind's book ‘Growth’ is that GDP, or the definition of growth, is a concept of our own making. It responds to the times and can also be modified. If not, it modifies itself.

Another key message is that it is necessary to make choices in the economy. Efforts can be made to avoid choices or reduce the pressures to make any, or a choice can be accepted as such.

The first option is to try and avoid choices. A case in point is growth that benefits everybody and therefore no tradeoffs are needed to be evaluated and weighted. Choices can be made easier by things like the reduced cost of consumption of solar and wind power that lessens the need to choose between growth and the environment. Third, if nothing else works, the choice, or ‘trade-off’, can be accepted as such. Then, it is a question of what is valued and how much. These, in turn, often amount to political choices with social implications.

Companies too need to make choices. They can be strategic choices and choices between short-term or long-term gain and cash flow. The above three approaches to choices can also apply to businesses, as well as to us as citizens. A well-known business leader once wisely said that if you have two options you can choose both.

In conclusion

Societies are geared for growth. More specifically, we are stuck with the current definition of gross national product. Luckily, the content and definition of GDP is changing. Now it consists mostly of services, and increasingly of the circular economy. This change alone suggests that future growth may consist of something other than what we are used to. Here and now, we are prisoners to the circumstances even though major structural changes are taking place as we speak. For want of a better project, let us promote GDP growth as we understand it today.

Writer is VER's CEO Timo Löyttyniemi

TLö blogi 2020

Recent posts

2024-11-28 at 14:23
2024-10-25 at 10:56
2024-10-10 at 13:15

Tags

acceleration active investing added value AI alternative investments asset classes austerity measures authoritarian governments baby boom baseline capitalism carbon border tax carbon emissions carbon footprint carbon intensity carbon neutrality carbon risk carbon tax carbon-neutral economy carbon-neutrality career central banks choices circular economy climate change climate commitments climate crisis CO2 emissions collateral commercial paper market commodities concentrated markets contingency plan contrarian corona crisis coronavirus coronavirus crisis countermeasures covid crisis covid economy crises crisis crypto currencies currencies debt burden debt structures decision-making defence industry defence policy defence technology degrowth democracy demographic trends demography dependency ratio depression derivatives development digital money digitalisation dilution disease monitoring system diversification Draghi ECB economic competition economic development economic growth economic policy economic system economy effective treatment electricity exchanges emergency measures employment figures energy export energy exports energy imports energy prices energy war environmental policy equity market equity markets escalation ESG EU EU elections euribor Europe exchange rates expected returns external borrowing FAAMG Fed financial crisis financial market financial markets financial stability Finnish Centre for Pensions (ETK) fiscal policy fixed income investments fixed-income investments forecasting fossil fuels free trade funding ratio funds GDP geopolitics global trade globalisation globalization government debt government finances green growth green technology green transition Growth healthcare systems hedge funds illiquid assets increase in prices indebtedness index investing index weighting indices inflation Innovations institutional investor institutional investors interest level interest rate interest rate level interest rates internal market international trade investment investment beliefs investment environment investment returns investment risk investments investments contribution approach joint debt Kauppalehti level of risk liberalism long-term return low-carbon economy market crash market economy market forces market interest rate market movements market portfolio market rallies market reaction markets megatrends miracle momentum monetary policy ownership policy pandemic pension investments pension investors pension liability pension promise pension system pension systems planning political decision-making portfolio structure positive side effect predatory traders pre-funding preparedness presidential elections price fall private equity private markets protectionism real estate investment real estate investments real estate market real estate sector rearmament recession regulation renewable energy renewable natural resources rescue packages responsibility restrictions retirement retirement age returns on investments risk bearer risk level risk management risk profile Russia sanctions scenarios security investments short squeeze sovereign debt spill-over effect stagflation state state ownership stimulation stimulation packages stock exchange stock market stock markets stock prices stock-exchange markets stocks strategic allocation strategic autonomy strategy success support measures supportive actions sustainability target retirement age taxation taxes technology the leading powers The United States timeframe for liabilities timing totalitarianism transition risk Trump trumponomics uncertainty venture capital virus war war of aggression wealth welfare state